Scotland's next manager. 5000 Miles Away

 


Scotland's national football team has been on a depressing struggle in recent times. Despite qualifying for 2 consecutive Euro's, the feeling around Steve Clarke has been diminishing in recent months. No competive win in 400 days, one win in 15 games (against Gibraltar) and the general negative style of play has led to many fans to question if Clarke should lead the 2026 World Cup Qualifiers. 


But who should be the man to replace him, should the SFA pull the plug on the Clarke-ball tenure. A few names seem to regularly come up, with Kilmarnock's Derek McInnes and David Moyles being the names thrown up by fans, pundits and bookies alike. And whilst there are certainly arguments for and against these potenial new national team managers, there is one man who has yet to appear in the conversation to take over. That man is Japanese coach Toru Oniki.


A foreign coach for Scotland? Well that hasn't happened since Berti Vogts, 22 years ago. This of course was a disaster appointment, with Vogts only winning 8 games out of a possible 31 and despite his Scottish attire, he left under a dark cloud, especially with members of the Tartan Army. So why on earth should we potentially repeat that with another foreign coach, a coach from Asia and not Europe at that? And it is simple. Oniki is the complete opposite of Steve Clarke. A complete modern posession based style of football that encourages goals to be scored and chances to be continious. When asked about his clubs ambition in the 2021 season, Oniki said "To win the title by playing attacking football that is fun for the players to play and fun for the spectators to watch". A massive difference between this and a back 5 with no shots for 80 minutes

So who is Toru Oniki? Well he is the Kawasaki Frontale manager and despite it being his one and only job in coaching, he boasts an incredible resume. 216 wins in 382 games, 4 J league titles, 2 Emporers cups, 1 J League cup and 3 Japanese super cups. All of this in 7 years. Oh and a +380 goal difference. He is also the coach that developed Reo Hatate (Celtic), Kaoro Mitoma (Brighton), Hidemasa Morita (Sporting) and Ao Tanaka (Leeds). Oniki plays a 4-3-3 attacking formation typically and that seems to suit Scotland at the moment. A midfield 3 of Gilmour, Mctominay and Mcginn? Gies some of that. He is also willing to play younger players that suit his formation, which should give some of the more younger players a chance (Lennon Miller!!) instead of the usual names that have had Scotland fans shaking their head at when looking at the team sheet.

Despite his high emphasis on attacking football, Oniki still focuses on keeping a solid defensive backline. Under previous manager Yahiro Kazama, Kawasaki conceded an average of 46.2 goals per season. Under Oniki, it has went to 30.4 per season. Attacking wise it has went from 60.4 goals scored to 70.8 per season under Oniki. Prior to Toru Oniki taking over, Kwasaki Frontale had never won the J league title. They have won it 4 times since. And the style of play has garnered praise from former players. Michael Fitzgerald, former player of Kawasaki said, " The environment at Kawasaki is top class, it’s the best I’ve been in,” the 33-year-old said.

You’ve got these guys that are at the top of the J.League, but it doesn’t matter if they’re in the team or not in the team, everyone is just one hundred percent at training. No one questions ‘why am I on the bench?’ everyone is just waiting for an opportunity to play.

“And I think that has been a big part of the success, it’s not just the eleven players who are playing every week, the whole team is just such a tight knit unit.”


Some Scotland fans will be totally against the idea of a foreign coach and this could be understandable. But I truly believe in order for Scotland to progress and ultimately make a mark in major international competitions, we need to appoint a manager with domestic success, a modern attacking football mindset and a positive happy attitude. I do not think McInnes or Moyes, despite their successes as coaches match Toru Oniki and I think the SFA need to make a dramatic change in the next appointment or more and more fans are going to simply stop caring for their own national team.




Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Ronnie Edwards Scout Report

Image
  Date of birth: 28 March 2003 Country: England Position: Central Defender/ Central Defensive Midfield Height: 180cm Preferred foot: Right Club: Peterborough United When you look at a modern central defender there is usually one of two play styles he has adopted. Either the traditional centre back who puts his foot through the ball up the park and dives into tackles but cannot play from the back, or the more modern player who is comfortable with the ball at his feet often at the expense of some of the more standard defensive skill set. Ronnie Edwards however is a very rare breed of player as he is the definition of modern meets classic. Ronnie Edwards has been a first team regular at Peterborough since joining from Barnet's under 18 squad in 2020. He has quickly became a fans favourite, also winning 4 club awards at the end of the 2021/22 season and he has only gone from strength to strength since with a call up to Englands under 20 squad for the world cup in 2023 starting all 4 ga
Read more

Sebastian Nanasi Scout Report

Image
  Date of birth: 16 May 2002 Country: Sweden Position: Lw Height: 178cm Preferred foot: Right Club: Malmo FF The Swedish Allsvenkan is always a gold mine for scouts and clubs alike looking for young talent playing big minutes in a competitive standing and Sebastian Nanasi has been a standout for the past few seasons with his potential and ability alike on the up and up.  In the 2023 season, Nanasi notched up 2,495 minutes across 20 games notching up 11 goals and 7 assists. Already this season he has appeared in 12 games, starting all and adding 5 goals and 7 assists already, as well as finding himself in the team of the week 8 times.  5 goals is very impressive when you take a look at the stats, averaging 2.3 shots and 0.9 hitting the target. Majority of his shot's come from his fantastic agility, often beating his man and cutting inside and firing at the goal. A goal conversion of 19% is fantastic giving he is often on the wing. All of his goals this season have been from inside t
Read more

Kento Tachibanada- Scout Report

Image
  Date of birth:  29 May 1998 Country: Japan Position: Central Midfielder/ Defensive Midfield Height: 168cm Preferred foot: Right Club: Kawasaki Frontale Midfielders in the modern day compared to the previous era's look vastly different. There is a lot more work, a lot more pressing to go with the traditional skills. Although many midfielders have adapted to the change, many have not, however in the J league the box to box midfielder is the norm and I don't think there are many more that standout than Kawasaki Frontale's Kento Tachibanada. Captain Kento has been with Kawasaki since 2020 having followed in the path of many Japanese players by coming into professional football directly from university. Having being made captain in 2023 he has cemented himself as first choice on the team sheet for the successful J league club. In his first season with the club he made 32 appearances helping the club win it's first J league title and his performances on the pitch have only
Read more